Hornberger's Blog

Hornberger's Blog is a daily libertarian blog written by Jacob G. Hornberger, founder and president of FFF.
Here's the RSS feed or subscribe to our FFF Email Update to receive Hornberger’s Blog daily.

Bring the Troops Home, Mr. President

by

NOTE: We held our “National Security State and JFK” conference last Saturday and it turned out to be absolutely fantastic. All 11 presentations were profound, interesting, and captivating. We videotaped the entire conference, and all the videos will be posted as soon as possible on FFF’s website. You will also be able to watch them on television because C-SPAN recorded the conference in its entirety. (We are not sure when.) Thank you to everyone who attended (140 attendance). The audience clearly energized all of the speakers to give some of the best and most insightful talks I have ever seen. Thank you to all the speakers for accepting our invitation to speak at the conference. And thanks to the people who generously funded the conference.

*****

Another terrorist attack in London, and more predictable responses from President Trump, British Prime Minister May, other public officials, and the mainstream press. We have to crack down on terrorism. The problem is with extremist Muslims. They hate us for our freedom and values. Don’t be afraid. Go about your daily lives as if nothing has happened.

And, of course, not one single word of the U.S. government’s interventionist foreign policy in the Middle East and Afghanistan, which has entailed killing Muslims and other for at least 25 years and which continues unabated to this day, a policy with which the British government has partnered and supported since its inception.

Why not even a peep about more terrorist retaliation from U.S. foreign interventionism?

Isn’t the answer obvious? If they mentioned that, that would cause people to ask a very basic question: Is the interventionism worth the death and destruction that comes as “blowback,” the term that the noted scholar Chalmers Johnson used to title his excellent and profound book: Blowback: The Costs and Consequences of American Empire?

That’s the last question that U.S. officials and British officials want Americans or British citizens to ask. They don’t want their citizens to be questioning or challenging the massive, ongoing death and destruction that the U.S. military and CIA have been wreaking and continue to wreak in that part of the world, with the full support of the British (and French and other) governments.

The Swiss share many of the same freedoms and values that Americans, British, and French share. How come the extreme Muslim terrorists aren’t attacking the Swiss? Is that just a coincidence?

Nope. There is nothing coincidental about it. It’s because Switzerland hasn’t been killing Muslims and others in the Middle East and Afghanistan for 25 years, as the U.S. government (and its partners) has. Unlike England and France, Switzerland has  steadfastly refused to partner with the U.S. government and its 25-year campaign to wreak death and destruction across the Middle East and Afghanistan.

Britain, in contrast, has partnered with the U.S. military machine. It still does. So has France. It still does too.

Thus, while U.S. and British officials continue to exclaim against “extremist Muslims,” they conveniently ignore that there is a common denominator among the nations that such extremist Muslims are targeting: the nations whose military forces continue wreaking death and destruction in the Middle East and Afghanistan.

The basic problem is that U.S. and British officials, along with the mainstream press, view U.S. interventionism as a given. The American and British citizenry are not supposed to question that. They’re just supposed to accept it as a permanent condition in life.

But question and challenge is precisely what Americans, British, French, and every other citizen whose government continues to partner with the U.S. death machine in the Middle East and Afghanistan need to do. The time for ending deference to the authority and expertise of the Pentagon, CIA, and other national-security state officials has arrived, especially with more innocent people, including children, regularly losing their lives as a consequence of U.S. (and allied) interventionism in that part of the world.

What would happen if U.S. troops and the CIA (and their willing partners) were to suddenly withdraw their forces from that part of the world?

Government officials would say, “That would mean a loss of face for the U.S. government and its partners.” My response: Who cares? What’s worth more — the lives of innocent victims of terrorist retaliation or saving face for government officials?

They say: But ISIS might take over Iraq and the Taliban might again take over Afghanistan. If they do, then does that mean that they are then coming to get us and force us to study the Koran? Or does it mean that they are going to cross the Atlantic with millions of Afghan and Iraqi troops, hundreds of thousands of transport ships and planes, and trillions of dollars in supplies, and then conquer and occupy the United States?

That’s ridiculous. Such fears are totally irrational. The terrorists are not coming to get us. Neither are the Muslims, communists, illegal aliens, drug dealers, and other scary things. All that it would mean is that there might be two more regimes in the world that hate the U.S. government. They would be added to North Korea, Venezuela, Nicaragua, and other regimes that hate the U.S. government. Hatred for the U.S. government doesn’t equate to invasion and conquest of the United States. It’s only imperialist regimes that concern themselves with installing the “right” regimes in foreign countries.

It’s time for the U.S. government (and the British and the French governments) to leave that part of the world alone. Don’t forget, after all, that it was the U.S. interventions, invasions, and occupations of both Afghanistan and Iraq that caused, fueled, or expanded the strife, civil wars, chaos, crises, anti-U.S. terrorism (including ISIS), death, destruction, and massive refugee crisis in Europe.

Ever since 1990, the mindset in the U.S. national-security bureaucracy has been: “We will keep killing people until we get it right, no matter how many people die as a result of terrorist retaliation. And we will keep infringing on the freedom and privacy of own own citizens in the hopes of keeping them safe from the enemies we are producing.”

But they haven’t gotten it right, notwithstanding 25 years of continuous death, destruction, and chaos. And they are never going to get it right because interventionism is an inherently defective paradigm.

It’s time for U.S. troops to be ordered home from that part of the world, just U.S. troops were ordered home from Lebanon in 1983 after 241 U.S. soldiers were killed in a terrorist bombing in Beirut. It is to the credit of President Reagan, who ordered the withdrawal, that he placed a higher value on the lives of the remaining troops than on the need of U.S. officials to “save face.”

Bring them home, Mr. President. The deaths of more people over there and at home is not worth even one more day of intervention.

This post was written by:

Jacob G. Hornberger is founder and president of The Future of Freedom Foundation. He was born and raised in Laredo, Texas, and received his B.A. in economics from Virginia Military Institute and his law degree from the University of Texas. He was a trial attorney for twelve years in Texas. He also was an adjunct professor at the University of Dallas, where he taught law and economics. In 1987, Mr. Hornberger left the practice of law to become director of programs at the Foundation for Economic Education. He has advanced freedom and free markets on talk-radio stations all across the country as well as on Fox News’ Neil Cavuto and Greta van Susteren shows and he appeared as a regular commentator on Judge Andrew Napolitano’s show Freedom Watch. View these interviews at LewRockwell.com and from Full Context. Send him email.