|
Send to a friend
DAREs Dying Gasp
by James Bovard, September 2000
The nations most popular drug
education program may be on the ropes. The Drug Abuse Resistance
Education (DARE) program is increasingly being tossed out of school
systems as the evidence of its failure to deter drug use becomes
overwhelming.
DARE was the brainchild of Los
Angeles Police Department chief Daryl Gates, who launched the program in
the early 1980s. More than 20 million students receive DARE training each
school day; DARE is taught in every state and in three-quarters of the
nations school districts. The DARE curriculum is taught by police
primarily to fifth- and sixth-graders, though children in kindergarten and
in high school also receive DARE instruction. The police are supposed to
serve as role models and trusted confidants.
America is deluged with DARE
paraphernalia including bears, bumper stickers, buttons, hats, and
jeeps. DARE has everything except good results. Many independent
experts have found that DARE miserably fails students:
The federal Bureau of Justice Assistance paid $300,000 to
the Research Triangle Institute (RTI), a North Carolina research firm, to
analyze DAREs effectiveness. The RTI study found that DARE failed
to significantly reduce drug use. Researchers warned that DARE
could be taking the place of other, more beneficial drug-use
curricula.
Dennis Rosenbaum, professor of criminal justice studies at
the University of Illinois at Chicago, surveyed and tracked 1800 kids who
had DARE training and concluded in 1998 that suburban students
who participated in DARE reported significantly higher rates of drug use
than suburban students who did not participate in the
program.
A 1999 study by the California legislative analysts
office concluded that DARE didnt keep children from using
drugs. In fact, it found that suburban kids who took DARE were more likely
than others to drink, smoke and take drugs, the Los Angeles Times
reported.
A 1999 University of Kentucky study, funded by the National
Institutes of Health, examined the effect of DARE on students
behavior over the subsequent 10 years. The report concluded: Our
results are consistent in documenting the absence of beneficial effects
associated with the DARE program. This was true whether the outcome
consisted of actual drug use or merely attitudes toward drug use.
One Kentucky researcher observed: The only difference was that
those who received D.A.R.E. reported slightly lower levels of self-esteem
at age 20.
Salt Lake City mayor Rocky Anderson
recently denounced DARE as a fraud on the people of
America. Anderson, who yanked DARE from Salt Lake City schools,
complained: For far too long, drug-prevention policies have been
driven by mindless adherence to a wasteful, ineffective, feel-good
program. DARE has been a huge public-relations success but a failure at
accomplishing the goal of long-term drug-abuse prevention.
DARE America president Glenn Levant
defends DARE by pointing to the reported 13 percent decline in teenage
drug use in the most recent annual survey. However, the percentage of
eighth-graders who used marijuana, cocaine, and LSD tripled between
1991 and 1997. DARE cannot claim credit for the most recent decline
without accepting blame for the huge increase in the preceding years
at a time when DARE already saturated the nations public
schools.
DARE suffered a stunning defeat last
April that could cripple its ability to stifle criticism. Federal judge
Virginia Phillips, in a case involving DARE Americas libel suit
against Rolling Stone magazine, ruled that there was substantial
truth to the charges that DARE had sought to suppress
scientific research critical of DARE and had attempted to
silence researchers at the Research Triangle Institute, editors at the
American Journal of Public Health, and producers at Dateline:
NBC.
DAREs feel-good photo
opportunities are no substitute for effective drug education. American
children deserve something than a drug program that fails to persuasively
inform and warn them of the danger of narcotics. Politicians, school
officials, and police need the courage to admit that DARE is a dud.
James Bovard is the author of
Feeling Your Pain: The Explosion and Abuse of Government Power
in the Clinton-Gore Years (St. Martins Press, August
2000). This article is adapted from an essay published by The Future of
Freedom Foundation in Fairfax, Va. (www.fff.org).
Send to a friend
back to top
Subscribe to Freedom Daily.
|