|
Printer Friendly PDF Format
Subscribe to FFF Email Update
Subscribe to Freedom Daily
DONATE TO FFF
The Superpower Myth
by
Sheldon Richman,
October 18, 2006
What does it mean to be the worlds only superpower?
Like Gulliver in Lilliput, the U.S. government is bogged down in Iraq and Afghanistan, and now faces the emergence of two new nuclear powers in North Korea and Iran. There seems to be nothing President Bush can do about it.
He sent UN Ambassador John Bolton to the Security Council, where he won sanctions on North Korea for its nuclear test. According to the New York Times, the Security Council resolution primarily ... bars the sale or transfer of material that could be used to make nuclear, biological and chemical weapons or ballistic missiles, and it bans international travel and freezes the overseas assets of people associated with the Norths weapons programs.
The resolution also calls on all countries to inspect cargo going in and out of North Korea to detect illicit weapons. This sounds like a measure designed to force a clash with Kim Jong Il. What happens when that occurs?
We must bear in mind that nothing is more resilient than
the black market. For decades the U.S. government has
tried to keep illegal drugs from entering the country. It
has been unable to keep them out of the prisons.
So sanctions may be little more than window dressing. As
the Times reported, But Chinas
refusal to take part in searches, and Russias
seeming annoyance at the end of the process, immediately
raised questions about how effective the
resolutions execution could be.
No one therefore should sleep better because the Security
Council has acted. Some want to see the Bush
administration engage Kim in one-on-one negotiations. But
negotiations mean that each side offers something. What
would the United States offer? In the past it has
provided aid, but this is objectionable on two counts.
First, previous aid didnt keep Kim from pursuing
his nuclear program. More important, American taxpayers
should not be forced to assist Kims evil, decrepit
regime. For one thing, while assistance would help
him, it would do little for the long-suffering
North Korean people. Moreover, the North Korean
government is almost universally condemned because it
flouts the rights of its people. Where is the
logic in the Bush administrations flouting the
rights of Americans in dealing with Kims
government?
There is something the administration could offer, but
its not likely to want to do so. It could agree to
remove the 37,500 American troops from South Korea, to
end the alliance with Seoul, and to pledge never to start
a war, including an economic war, with North Korea.
Thats something an American president should have
done a long time ago. The North Korean government has had
grounds for distrusting the United States since the war
in the early 1950s, which began when North Korea invaded
South Korea. U.S. participation in that war President Harry
Trumans undeclared police action was
unjustified from the standpoint of limited government and
the safety of the American people. But it told the world
that the United States was assuming the role of world
policeman. That couldnt help but create fear of
and enemies for America. It also gave North
Koreas communist dictator a powerful propaganda
tool with which to keep the North Koreans scared and
loyal.
Now, and especially after what happened to Saddam Hussein
in Iraq, is anyone mystified by Kims desire for a
nuclear weapon?
Short of assurances to North Korea, there is nothing
President Bush can properly do to reduce the potential
nuclear danger from North Korea. Even he seems to realize
that war would be a disaster for everyone concerned.
Nuclear weapons are part of the modern world. Iran and
other nations will soon join the club. The U.S.
government, the only government to use nuclear weapons
and on innocent civilians to boot has
little moral standing to lecture others. Moreover, any
government efforts to protect us will likely make things
worse through corruption and ineptitude. If there are
technological ways to shield us from a nuclear attack,
the government should step aside and let private
enterprise discover them.
Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation, author of Tethered Citizens: Time to Repeal the Welfare State, and editor of The Freeman magazine. He will be among the 22 speakers at FFFs upcoming conference on June 1-4 in Reston, Virginia, entitled Restoring the Republic: Foreign Policy and Civil Liberties. Visit his blog Free Association at www.sheldonrichman.com. Send him email.
|