|
Printer Friendly PDF Format
Subscribe to FFF Email Update
Subscribe to Freedom Daily
DONATE TO FFF
Mr. Bush, Are You There?
by
Sheldon Richman,
August 4, 2006
If President Bush is trying to convince us that he hasnt the slightest
understanding of the Middle East, then hes doing an outstanding job.
Every statement he makes and this goes for his secretary of State,
Condoleezza Rice, too is soaked in ignorance. Any American who is
paying attention should be shuddering to think that this man is running U.S.
foreign policy.
Lets ignore Rices statement that the destruction of Lebanon
represents the birth pangs of a new Middle East. To equate
Israels reckless disregard for Arab life, as in Qana, with a
mothers giving birth is obscene.
President Bush, in his usual arrogant way, shows that he knows nothing of
what he speaks. He still opposes an immediate ceasefire, explaining on Fox
News, See, stopping for the sake of stopping [!], you know, is
is is can be OK, except it wont address the root cause
of the problem. Which is? And the root cause of the problem is
armed militias firing rockets from a sovereign nation into another sovereign
nation.
Is he aware that before 1982 Hezbollah did not exist?
Does he have a clue what brought it into existence? He might be inclined to
think that it arose to grab Israeli soldiers across the border. But in fact
it arose after Israel invaded Lebanon despite a year of quiet on that
border in order to wipe out Palestinian refugees displaced by
Israels earlier program to redeem Arab-owed land. Israel
remained in southern Lebanon for 18 years. It even set up its own Christian
Lebanese militia to do some of the dirty work.
Israeli forces killed tens of thousands of Lebanese during the siege of
Beirut and the occupation. The Israeli-sponsored militia slaughtered
hundreds of Palestinians in refugee camps like cattle. Israel had its way
with Lebanon, and no one could do anything about it.
Hezbollah organized to resist that illegal occupation.
This is legitimate under international law, not to mention moral law. Not
every Hezbollah action has been defensible, but most people would say the
same about Israel. We should not lose sight of the context or the fact that
the U.S. government assisted Israel in virtually every respect, especially
by the provision of money and weapons.
President Bush says Hezbollah must be disarmed. Why? So Israel can continue
to treat southern Lebanon like a door mat? Much is made of Israels
departure from Lebanon in 2000, as though this were some magnanimous
gesture. It was driven out by Hezbollah, which not only defended the
Lebanese, but provided a variety of services to the suffering Shiites
schools, medical clinics, homes, and more. When Lebanon had
elections, Hezbollah members were elected to Parliament. Israel withdrew,
but it has not respected the border. As documented by the UN, its warplanes
violated Lebanese airspace daily.
Heres what Israeli analyst Ran HaCohen writes:
Since Israel withdrew from Lebanon six years ago, then, it hasnt
given its northern neighbor even a single day of quiet.... And just as
Israelis wonder about the purpose of Hezbollahs missile arsenal, so
could Lebanon, and so should we all, wonder what was the purpose of the
thousands of Israeli overflights and sonic booms in Lebanons sky: was
it to gather some information not available to Israels satellites
anyway, or, much more likely, just to terrorize Lebanons population by
showing them that we violate their sovereignty whenever we deem it
necessary?
In this light Hezbollahs seizing of Israeli soldiers looks less like
unprovoked aggression, doesnt it? It didnt fire rockets at
Israel until the IDF started pounding the very core of Lebanese society.
But Hezbollah gets arms from Iran, President Bush
protests. Can he really say this with a straight face?
Does Israel not get arms the most sophisticated
known from a foreign power? Who speeded up
shipment of precision bombs to facilitate the current
demolition of Lebanese civil society? Hello? Mr. Bush,
are you there?
Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation, author of Tethered Citizens: Time to Repeal the Welfare State, and editor of The Freeman magazine. Visit his blog Free Association at www.sheldonrichman.com. Send him email.
|