|
Send to a friend
Printer Friendly PDF Format
Subscribe to FFF Email Update
Subscribe to Freedom Daily
Must Our Senators Embarrass Us So?
by
Sheldon Richman,
November 14, 2005
An open letter to the American people:
Like you, I was embarrassed by those senators holding the hearing on oil-company prices and profits the other day.
Hard to believe that adults could act so childishly before television cameras.
Lets face it: those senators made such fools of themselves for one reason only to impress you and me. Of course, we saw through their stunt.
Pete Domenici, the Republican senator from New Mexico, told the oil executives, Americans have been experiencing painful prices at the pump whether you think so or not, they think so. The oil companies owe the American people an explanation.
Indeed, we did see oil and gas prices rise, although they
were already falling as the senators engaged in their
tomfoolery. But you and I understand why they went up.
World demand for oil has grown, and then hurricanes hit a
key refining area. So when Domenici says the American
people are owed an explanation, he is insulting your
intelligence. He pretends that you dont know that
the explanation is available in any economics book.
Its called supply and demand.
Byron L. Dorgan, the North Dakota Democratic senator,
chimed in, None of us knows much about pricing. But
we see the pain of the consumers, and we see the gains of
the companies. Now there was a refreshing
confession of ignorance. Thats rare in the U.S.
Senate. He may not know how the price system works, but
you and I do. We understand that when supply falls and
demand increases, a process kicks in that encourages new
production and reduced consumption. The pain is therefore
temporary if the market process is protected from
meddling politicians who admit they know nothing about
economics.
Want to hear something funny? When ExxonMobil chairman
Lee Raymond explained the price system to the senators,
Domenici said, I dont think my constituents
are going to understand your answer. See? The
politicians think youre dummies. I suggest that
Domenici speak for himself, and perhaps Byron Dorgan. The
rest of us have heard of supply and demand.
Heres another laugher. House Speaker Dennis Hastert
said he had a very frank discussion in which
he told Raymond he should invest the companys
profits in expanded production. Wow! Ill bet
Raymond never thought of that! What would businessmen do
without these guys? (Psst: the companies have been
investing billions in new production.)
Im curious: altogether how many gallons of gasoline
have Hastert, Domenici, and Dorgan produced?
Apparently, the Bush administration didnt want to
be left out of the silliness. Spokesman Scott McClellan
contributed this gem: Energy prices have been too
high and energy companies have realized significant
increases in profits. Its important that the
private sector be good corporate citizens and invest in
the energy infrastructure and support those who are in
need. Thank goodness we have such wise people
running the country. But is expanding production really a
matter of good citizenship? I thought it was a way to
make more money for the company owners, who might be you
and me, since we could own stock through our 401(k)s. And
whats this about supporting those in need?
Isnt producing energy, which is increasingly
cheaper in real terms, support enough?
The senators kept pointing out that ExxonMobil made
nearly $10 billion in the last quarter. But that was on
$100 billion in sales. In other words, the return during
an extraordinarily profitable period amounted to less
than 10 cents on the dollar. For years, the oil
companies profits were below the industrial
average. You can look it up.
So here is my message to you, my fellow Americans. We can
spare ourselves such foolishness in the future. How?
Write your senators and representatives today and tell
them you support the free market because it is the only
way to have cheap, plentiful energy. And tell them you
want no windfall-profits tax or regulations because they
will only hurt us. Yes, take away any oil-company
subsidies, but leave the producers alone.
Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation, author of Tethered Citizens: Time to Repeal the Welfare State, and editor of The Freeman magazine. Send him email.
|