From the way some people talk in this political season,
youd think all the good jobs are being shipped to
India, leaving nothing for Americans to do but flip
hamburgers and shine shoes.
Dont expect to hear sensible talk about economics
in an election year. It doesnt fit into sound
bites. Demagogues have it easier, since their consciences
dont demand evidence for their allegations.
That said, there is reason to discount most of what is
said to foment fear about outsourcing,
offshoring, and the other scare words bandied
about. The facts all run the other way.
Before getting to the details, lets go over some
basics. Trade is good. Why? Because it permits people to
take advantage of specialization and the division of
labor. As the great French economist Frédéric
Bastiat wrote in the 19th century, the division of labor
gives each individual access to products and services he
couldnt produce himself in a thousand years. You
dont need theory to see this. Think of all the
products you used since waking this morning. How much of
it could you have produced? Yet with even a modest
income, you used a cornucopia of products that would have
astounded the king of England a hundred years ago.
At any given moment there are things we cant have
because labor and resources are tied up making other
things. Thats too bad because there is stuff we
want or would want if we knew about it. How can we
get it? By becoming more efficient and freeing up labor
and resources. One way to do that is to hire
less-expensive labor to make things and perform services. When
we do that, the money saved is available for new
investment and jobs. Progress is always attended by the
shifting and destruction of jobs. (Who cries for the
unemployed slide-rule makers?) The time to worry is when
jobs dont change. Thats stagnation.
All of this is true even if the lower-cost labor is
located in India or China or Mexico. National boundaries,
at least in this sense, dont matter. Any time we
can have what we want at lower cost, labor and resources
are liberated for additional things to make our lives
better. We can have more for equal or less expenditure.
Wealth is created. Remember this when you hear Lou Dobbs,
Ralph Nader, and John Kerry trying to scare you.
Those folks are not only wrong in theory, they also are
wrong on the facts. No one knows precisely how many jobs
have been outsourced. But we do know some things. One is
that there is much insourcing; that is,
foreign companies are over here hiring lots of Americans.
According to the Organization for International
Investment, more jobs are being created by foreign
companies here than by home-grown firms. In 2001, 6.4
million jobs were created in the United States by foreign
companies, 34 percent in manufacturing. Walter Wriston,
the former chairman of Citibank, is convinced that
the balance of jobs we import from abroad greatly
exceeds the jobs we export abroad. He points out
that Honda, Novartis, and Samsung are just a few examples
of foreign firms setting up shop here and hiring
Americans. Foreign companies with U.S. facilities
dont sell just in the American market. They export
too.
Another indicator is the surplus the American economy
runs in information-technology services. According to
Information Week, Despite the export
of many computer-programming and call-center jobs, U.S.
companies bring in far more revenue from
business-technology services than they pay to foreign
providers. In 2001 the surplus in IT services was
almost $2 billion. As a rule, it is silly to obsess over
trade surpluses and deficits, which in themselves are
meaningless. But the services surplus puts the current
fear-mongering in perspective.
One more thing to consider: Catherine Mann, senior fellow
at the Institute for International Economics, says that
when computer jobs move abroad, more and better-paying
jobs take their place.
There is something government can do: repeal all laws and
taxes that make it more expensive for companies to hire
workers. Thats a good idea any time.
Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation, author of Tethered Citizens: Time to Repeal the Welfare State, and editor of The Freeman magazine. Send him email.
|
Send to a friend
Printer Friendly PDF Format
Subscribe to FFF Email Update
Subscribe to Freedom Daily
|
|
|
|